HOME

2008 Annual Meeting

SOUTH ASIA SESSION 7

[ South Asia Sessions, Table of Contents | Panels by World Area Main Menu ]


Individual Papers: Shaping Public Consciousness in South and Southeast Asia

Organizer: Amrita Basu, Amherst College
Chair: Arjun Guneratne, Macalaster College

Warfare and Worship: Elephants in Cankam Literature
Rajmohan Ramanathapillai, Gettysburg College
Classical Tamil poetry from the Cankam period, the first and the third century, offers a precious opportunity to see the richness of the landscape and wildlife in South India. This poetry also reveals that elephants were highly valued. Puranuru, or war poetry, within the Cankam era, describes the exterior world of politics and battlefields, with glorious heroes referring to elephants nearly 150 times in 400 songs. But what is the relationship between elephants and these war-loving kings? Kailasapathy argues that the necessity for celebrating elephants is to give attention to the “strength and power of the devastation they cause”. Rutting male elephants were feared and respected. Heroes of war jealously admired the unpredictability and wrath of a rutting elephant. Bards compared these elephants to the indiscriminate character of ruthless fighters. To slay a rutting elephant or to be slain by it in combat brought immortality to a hero. The notion of maram, which means valor and bravery, refers equally to a hero or elephant combatant. Above all, the use of elephants in war, to secure one’s kingdom or expand its power and wealth, was pragmatic. But how did elephant worship in India evolve from this context as it came out of the cruelty of exposing this animal to warfare? This paper will argue that as nature worship came out of necessity in the Vedic period, the worship of elephant in South India and India general was shaped by a necessity of a different kind.

Rewriting a Nationalist Narrative: State Power in India in the 1940s
Indivar Kamtekar, Jawaharlal Nehru University
The 1940s are usually seen in Indian history as the time of independence from British rule. This paper moves away from the common obsession with imperialism and nationalism to investigate the enduring effects of the Second World War on the relationship between Indian society and the state. Looking at the changes in the army and police forces, it shows how the coercive power of the state actually increased throughout the decade. The paper also traces how new forms of government activity, like rationing, began in this period. Economic controls—often assumed in independent India to be the outcome of a socialist ideology—were actually sired by a war economy. The economic policy structure under which the citizens of independent India lived ‘til the liberalization of 1991 was a child of the Second World War. And the war economy also fathered other children, who grew up to have lives of their own: very high rates of taxation, sales tax as a major source of revenue, very widespread tax evasion, and a bureaucratic mindset convinced that businessmen should do as they are told. The world-war mindsets encouraged living with shortages rather than overcoming them, damaged the ideology and practice of the market, and opened the door to the “License-Permit Raj”. During the decade associated with independence, Indian society came to be held more tightly within what was for some Indians an unwelcome embrace of the state.

Media Convergence and Hindi Newspapers: Changing Dynamics of News-Making Practices
Taberez A. Neyazi, National University of Singapore
The paper is an attempt to understand the changing face of Hindi newspapers through a case study of Dainik Bhaskar, that claims to be the largest read newspaper in India with multi-editions and being simultaneously present in Gujarati and English languages also. Through a qualitative content analysis of Dainik Bhaskar from 1980 to 2007 and participant observation to explore the activities in the newsroom, life of reporters, photographers, sub-editors, and editors, the paper unravels the changing dynamics of news-making practices. Furthermore, the advent of new media and the convergence of offline and online editions of Hindi newspapers are making readers conscious about local issues and problems, but at the same time, global response has been also visible to the local problem. The process of local news-making practices and the people involved in the process clearly reveal the cultural and political significance of Hindi newspapers and their orientation toward “reflexive modernity” that belies the thesis of “cultural imperialism”. Such a conclusion is based on my fieldwork experiences in Bhopal, India, and my long term involvement with people associated with Dainik Bhaskar.

Digital Stories: Rethinking Southeast Asian Ethnicity, Gender, and National Identity through Textiles and Dress
Cherubim A. Quizon, Seton Hall University
This project seeks to combine available Web 2.0 classroom technologies as tools for teaching about the peoples and cultures of Southeast Asia by following the cultural and historical trajectory of textiles and dress that ostensibly belong to a well-defined “tribe” or ethnic group. When students learn that intergroup relations in Southeast Asia follow dynamic models, such as that between upstream-downstream communities, Leach’s formulation of gumsa-gumlao modes of self-identification, or as performative roles of transgender individuals outside ascribed models of citizenship, it is equally important to rethink longstanding assumptions about how visual signals of a “tribe” are often mapped onto a single “tribal art style”. By following the “life cycle”, so to speak, of specific artifacts of cloth and clothing; by approaching them as material culture agents that derive multiple meanings in different contexts; and by actively relating these to a variety of textual material (from early modern travelers accounts to contemporary ethnographies), the project seeks to delineate both the fluidity of ethnic boundaries on one hand, and on the other, the ideological persistence of late-modern identity projects. Teaching advanced undergraduate students about the dynamics of Southeast Asian ethnicity, gender, and national identity using textile material culture includes tapping resources now on the internet that were once the purview of specialists. Consequently, intellectual property issues, responsible digital scholarship and the notion of a “creative commons” will also be addressed.

Balinese Babad: The Politics of Historical Expression, 18th Century to the Present
Robin Tatu, University of Hawai'i, Manoa
Composed since the early 18th century, Balinese babad are works that narrate the history of extended family groups, with the earliest manuscripts detailing the lineage of royal dynasties. Despite the dissolution of local kingdoms, the formation of the Republic of Indonesia, and the rise of modern academic history, babad remain for many Balinese an important means for defining the past. These works are notable for their fluidity, continuously being recomposed as well as presented in oral recitations and theatrical productions.
In this paper, I examine the politics of history-making in Bali and the ways in which babad are today employed by members of all levels in the society, often as a way to lay claim to status and heredity rights. I argue that to gain a more complete understanding of these negotiations, we need to look beyond the written works to the uses of babad as they are revised and updated in new editions, chanted and analyzed in pepaosan recitation, and excerpted and embodied in topeng dance-drama theatre, all within a religious context. As one example of a living local historical tradition, Balinese babad should offer insights for the study of other non-western historical traditions.